I've not played any of them, but then sea and air specific games aren't to my liking. I don't mind having those elements in some levels of a shooter like the Pearl Harbor opening of MoH: Pac Assault, but having it through a whole game is another thing.
I know some balk at reading reviews but the site I use if I can't glean enough info from players is GameRankings.com. Some of the sites they list ratings for (like Gamespot) also list user ratings.
GameRankings via their collection of review sites around the world averages Silent Hunter to rate in the following manner...
Part III...88%
Part I......81%
Part IV....78%
Part II.....71%
http://www.gamerankings.com/
|